Inter Basin Water Transfer link Project

Sustainable Development Networking Programme Bangladesh

Inter Basin Water Transfer Link Project of India

Home Feedback Contact us

 

Bangladesh's Perspective

 
Home
Inter Basin Water Transfer link Project
Indian National Perspective Plan
Persons Behind The Project
National Water Policy/Act
Scenario of Water Resources of India
Progress of Work So Far
Trans Boundary River Management
Bangladesh's Perspective


Bangladesh: Waiting for a miracle

Inam Ahmed and Aasha Mehreen Amin report from Bangladesh on the consequences of the Farakka Barrage across the main flow of the river near the border between the two countries, and on the need for more constructive water sharing.

As the sun's crimson glow spreads across the horizon, a dirty dilapidated truck bulldozes across the sandy, dry land that used to be the River Padma (the main flow in Bangladesh of the Ganges) before India's Farakka Barrage dried out its life. In the twilight, Abdul Barek, 35 prepares for a nightly sally across the border and mysteriously returns with his booty - a couple of smuggled Indian cows. Barek of Meherpur, Kushtia, in western Bangladesh, once a small farmer, now ekes out a living by smuggling Indian cows, sugar and other items. He was forced to sell off his land because of successive crop failures due to water withdrawal by India at Farakka Barrage.

"What else could I do ?" asks a wiry Barek, a few days stubble on his haggard face. "I received water from the Ganges- Kobadak (G-K) irrigation project. But then the pumps could not turn. I could not grow anything on my land for three consecutive

seasons. Meanwhile, my debts to the Mahajan (money lenders) began to pile up. So, I sold my land to settle my debt and took to smuggling."

Like Barek, many others have resorted to this illegal profession risking imprisonment, because it at least keeps them alive. About 120,000 farming families living in the G-K project area are suffering because the project has been bogged down by an acute water shortage in the River Padma that flows through India.

Women especially, have been victims of the effect of the Barrage. Saleh Begum, a mother of three small children of Mirpur thana does not know how she will feed them in the days to come. She has not heard from her husband Osman who left for Dhaka three months ago to find work after giving up on his profession as a boatman.

"With the rivers drying up, we have to walk miles to bring water for our daily washing, cooking and drinking," says Shimuli, 35, another village woman, "All the work at home has to be delayed and all this walking and carrying the heavy kolshi (pitcher) has given me a terrible backache."


Image: Fishermen at the River Padma show their empty nets. İAasha Amin

   
Many women who used to work in the rice mills are now jobless Nahar, 35, for example, is now a beggar in Meherpur town. "I was not a beggar," she says, "I used to work in the rice mills. But then business was bad as harvests were affected. There was not enough work for all the 20 women working in the mills, boiling and drying rice. Farm work also vanished as crops failed. I had no alternative but to go begging."

The water crisis originated when the Farakka Barrage, located 19 kilometres from the Indo-Bangladesh border, was commissioned in 1975. Since then the water flow in the Padma has been reduced by about 40 per cent.

The two neighbouring countries reached an agreement on Ganges water sharing in 1977 which expired in 1989. Since then there has not been any fresh agreement between the two countries making Farakka a blistering issue between them.

According to available statistics, Bangladesh recorded the lowest 9,200 cusec of water flow in 1993 which at present varies between 12,000 and 13,000 cusec in the dry season. Before commissioning the Barrage, the water flow fluctuated between 65,000 cusec and 70,000 cusec.

Meanwhile, as the water flow dwindled, the G-K project failed to irrigate about 48,000 hectares of dry cropland for high yielding crops last year. It is still uncertain how much of the 350,000 acres of the project will be covered this year, as the lean season starts. Government estimates put the loss due to the failure of the G-K project at over $75 million.

Tampering with the ecosystem which the Barrage has done, has had devastating effects on the environment. One of them has been the gradual death of the River Padma. From Charulia, under Mirpur thana of Kushtia; the once mighty Padma looks more like a broad expanse of dwindling waterway, scattered with shoals and sand dunes, conjuring unmistakable signs of desertification.

During the dry season, a period becoming increasingly longer with time, an enormous amount of silt is collected which remains even when the flood gates of the Barrage are opened, says Hasna Moudud, an active environmentalist who has been campaigning against the Barrage for years.

"This rise in siltation has made the flood prone areas even more vulnerable," says Moudad. "The after flood effects have also been strangely negative. Previously when the floods ended, the earth would be replenished and ready for new crops to be sown. Now the moisture evaporates so fast due to siltation that the soil is left completely dry and unfit for agriculture. Natural aquifers have also been destroyed in the process."

Already the north western and south western parts of Bangladesh are going through a process of desertification.

According to Bangladesh Water Development Board statistics, around four million acres of land have been affected by withdrawal of water resulting in irrigation loss, moisture depletion and increased salinity endangering the lives of about 40 million people.

"There is a strong misconception worldwide," says Moudud, "that Bangladesh is a country of too much water. It is true we have as many as 52 rivers coming from India. But we have absolutely no control over them and India has built dams on practically all of them or is planning to do so in the near future."

The continued evasion of the Indian authorities and its failure to recognize the adverse effects of Farakka has caused much bitterness In Bangladesh.

Other effects on the environment are equally frightening. The Gorai, once a major river, is almost dead and many others are in the process of drying up. About 17 per cent of the total Sundari trees of the Sundarbans, the world's largest estuarine swamp, have already fallen prey to the top-dying syndrome due to increased salinity, according to forest department officials. This is threatening the survival of the few Royal Bengal Tigers that are left.

While the ecological balance of the rivers are threatened, the misery of an estimated 40 million people continues to increase. Due to the increased salinity a newsprint mill and a power plant in the coastal Khulna region may have to close down, throwing large numbers out of work.

Since the breeding areas of fish have been affected and rivers dried up, many thousands of fishermen and boatmen have lost their only means of livelihood. Many have migrated to the cities and are now rickshaw-pullers or daily wage labourers, earning only a fraction of what they did before. "Most of the fishing villages in the Kushtia district of Khulna division in the south west region have virtually disappeared in recent years," says Ashok Swain, Assistant Professor, Uppsala University of Sweden, estimating that around two million people from Kushtia and Rajshahi have left without a trace. Two decades have passed since the building of a barrage that has been sucking out the life of Bangladesh. In the busy streets of capital Dhaka, Kafiluddin, 38, still dreams of returning to his village in Bheramara while he paddles his rickshaw through the impossible traffic jams and feels repulsed at the thought of going 'home' to the squalid slum he shares with his four-member family.

Three years ago he was a farmer harvesting his own paddy fields. Kafil cannot let go of the hope that someday the water will come back allowing him to return to his village home. Like him there are many others waiting for such a miracle to happen.

 

Inam Ahmed and Aasha Mehreen Amin are feature writers with the Daily Star in Bangladesh. Inam Ahmed is also a contributor to Rivers of Life (Panos/BCAS, London, 1994), which critically examines the Bangladesh Flood Action Plan.

 

 

Source: People & the Planet 1996

Bangladesh's Perspective
Water Resources of Bangladesh
Probable Impact on Bangladesh
Impact of Ganges Water Diversion on GDA
Probable Impacts on other Parts of Country
Bangladesh Experience on Ganges Water Sharing
Seminars on The Adverse Effect on Bangladesh for The Inter Basin Water Transfer Link Project of India
Response of Bangladesh

Home Feedback Contact us